
Stonewall: it’s the most famous single event in LGBTQ+ history, a piece of our community’s mythology that’s inspired queer people around the world.
And subsequently, an overwhelming number of rumors and falsehoods have attached themselves to that night. We argue over who threw “the first brick” or whether Marsha P. Johnson was there or not. A certain drag queen television competition (cough, cough) even told viewers that the devastation over Judy Garland’s death, just a few days earlier, was what pushed patrons to fight back against the police in 1969 (a claim no historians have found evidence for).
Fifty-seven years later, Martin Boyce is one of just a small number of people still alive who were at Stonewall on the night of the uprising. He was 21 at the time and a regular at Stonewall.
“I was there in the daytime once, and I looked around me, and it was horrifying. Black walls, uncleaned. But at night, that’s what amazed me. I looked around and it turned to magic. The people made it magic.”
And what does he make of all the myths? He’s quite fine with them, as it turns out.
I recently interviewed Martin at his apartment in NYC about what he saw that night, why the legends around Stonewall don’t bother him, and what it was like to attend college in “scare drag.”
This interview has been edited and condensed.
Jeffrey Masters: In the late ’50s, early ’60s as you were beginning to explore gay life, Christopher Street was a gathering point, a gathering space, right? When you were walking down Christopher Street, how did that differ from other streets in New York?
Martin Boyce: In the 1960s — if you know from West Side Story — everybody had a turf. Everyone had a turf. So all of a sudden Christopher Street became our street. It’s the only place you couldn’t get sucker punched. This is why Stonewall was so important: because they didn’t just invade a bar, which they did all the time. Our turf was gone. That made people fight. There was something to fight for, because we had a turf.
JM: What was the reputation of Stonewall at that time, before the uprising? What kind of bar was it?
MB: A dancing bar. The only dancing bar.
JM: What kind of music would they play?
MB: The best jukebox. Aretha Franklin and Marvin Gaye and the girl groups and Jefferson Airplane, all those people, all the hippest songs.
JM: I’m wondering what was appropriate. Could you kiss a man at that bar?
MB: If it lead to that, yeah, but you wouldn’t carry on because you couldn’t do that in a straight bar either. You could kiss somebody, but you couldn’t go too far.
JM: I’ve heard Stonewall described as a disgusting dive.
MB: It was.
JM: Is that accurate?
MB: Oh, absolutely. I was there in the daytime once, and I looked around me, and it was horrifying. Black walls, uncleaned. You really noticed there was no water in those sinks. But at night, that’s what amazed me. I looked around, and it turned to magic. The people made it magic.
JM: What kind of people were there?
MB: It was amazing because it was a gay bar with dancing, and everybody heard about it. It was such a rare thing. I often describe it as a gay Noah’s Ark. There were two or three of each kind of gay. Because gay was just not united. It was just an umbrella word for a bunch of groups that didn’t like each other. We all hated each other. All the gays hated each other.
JM: Oh, really?
MB: All of them. All the groups hated the other groups.
JM: What was your group?
MB: Scare drag.
JM: Explain what “scare drag” means for people, because we don’t use that term anymore.
MB: Like Boy George. Gender bending.
JM: Gender bending. Were you wearing a wig?
MB: No, no, no. We got the name from the full drag queens, who thought that it was scary. We weren’t going far enough to them.
JM: Were drag queens welcome at Stonewall?
MB: Not necessarily. They weren’t really welcomed anywhere, but they got there.
JM: They were welcome there more than other places?
MB: Oh, yeah. Because it was diverse. The Mafia didn’t want the crowd ever to become dominated by any one of the gay groups. If it became a Black bar, it became a Latin bar, if it became a gay bar, that meant only a certain amount of customers. But this was everybody.
JM: So they kept the customer base diverse.
MB: They made sure that it was balanced. There was a quota system. Not too many scare drags, not too many Blacks, not too many Latinos.
JM: So you would go there and they’d say, “Hey, we have too many scare drags tonight. Get out of here,” or, “We have too many Black people tonight”?
MB: They just didn’t let you in. That’s it.
JM: But you said nobody got along. Would there be dancing together, or was it separate?
MB: You were with your group. Stonewall taught us tolerance of ourselves. Because here we were trying to enjoy this bar, trying to enjoy dancing, winding up on the line for the men’s room, which was scary, and everybody hating it, right? The A-gays, they had the long bar, and they were working at Bloomingdale’s, had odd jobs, boys in the band. And they had the only running water, they had real drinks. And to get to where you wanted to, you had to pass them. It was a gauntlet. And they would just curse us out, because they blamed us for bringing all the trouble to it — the police, and us being outrageous, being feminine, making gays be described as feminine. They blamed us for everything.
JM: They must have hated you being in scare drag.
MB: Oh, they hated me. But on the other hand, I was very, very friendly, and occasionally they would make friends with me, but I was the exception. They were very nice queens, some of them, but they hated what I was doing.
JM: Take me to the night of the uprising. I believe you arrived at Stonewall after the police got there. Is that right? What did you see?
MB: Well, my friend, Bernie, and I were gonna go to Stonewall. We were gonna go, and then we ran into Tommy Smith, and Tommy said, “You’re not getting in,” because Tommy was a scare drag. So right away we knew we weren’t getting in, because Tommy said we couldn’t get in. That was it. We knew the quota was filled. That was it.
Okay, fine. It’s Friday night in New York, who cares? Stonewall was Stonewall, but it was not the only place. It was like we were gonna go, and if we couldn’t get in, we’d go somewhere else. It was not a big thing. It was a bar we wanted to try out. It had a bad reputation in many ways.
But we were gonna go, and we couldn’t get in. And we were on a stoop up from Stonewall, and I was talking to Bertie. We were thinking what we were gonna do, and then behind me was a rush of people. And I started hearing talk of a raid. And the rush behind me — the energy was strange. So I turned around, and sure enough, right by Stonewall was a paddy wagon, a police car with a bubble light going on and off and on and off. And I could see it reflected in the buildings, and it was just a mess. People were rushing away, gays who were afraid to even be near the thing.
JM: Bar raids were common at this point. What about what you saw told you that something special was going on?
MB: Nothing.
JM: Oh — nothing yet.
MB: Nothing. It was just the way the raid was. It was always the same thing. If there were any drag queens in the bar, they would come out to cheers. And the closet cases, trying to cover up their faces, would come out to jeers. And you watch it. I got there late — five, six, seven minutes late. I heard the cheers. I knew it was happening. And I got through and saw the paddy wagon. And there in front of Stonewall was a group of people that had made an amphitheater in front of the bar, like a circle with an open space. They were thrown out of the bar. People were watching. Everybody was just watching. But the cops were busy. Oh my God, they were busy. The paddy wagon was there. There was people in the darkness, crying — it was just awful. It was strange, but under their control.
And all of a sudden, this policeman started dragging this Latina queen out of the bar. She was the last one, and she was fighting him. I don’t know what she looked like even to this day, because she was so angular, so kinetic. I never got to see what she looked like. Horrible, ugly policeman with red hair, and he grabbed her and threw her in the back, got her to the back of the van. And we’re watching.
And he looked at us to show us this was gonna happen to us if we carried on. And all of a sudden, a foot came into vision from the van — with all these rhinestones, high heel, open-toe. We used to call them Joan Crawford fuck-me pumps. And there was a Joan Crawford fuck-me pump. And just the foot came out of the truck and knocked him on the shoulder and sent him flying.
JM: From inside this truck, she kicked him with her Joan Crawford fuck-me pumps?
MB: It was unbelievable. It was the most beautiful, amazing moment in the brawl to me. I still remember the jewels taking the light. And he went flying, and then some dust came up. Oh, she hit him. And we laughed. How could we not laugh? Our laughter was her doom. He got up, gave us a look, brushed himself off. He’s in the back of that truck, and all you heard was bone and flesh against metal and a dripping, dripping, horrible sound and the moaning screams of terror of whoever was also in there.
The crowd was shocked. Shocked. We were all shocked. We’ve all been in raids. We’ve all seen it. We’ve all went through it, but not this.
JM: So that was kind of the turning point for you, that it became more than just a normal raid?
MB: No. Nothing happened. It was always like it always was. We just had to watch what was going on. And now this was a new thing. In the middle of the city, that they could do it now, not just on the corner. Now it’s open territory. And a lot of us thought, somehow, about what our future could be now. Because here it was, middle of the city, tourists everywhere looking, and they can do it.
JM: Are you saying that the other gay bars were more hidden and secluded?
MB: The docks, or non-tourist neighborhoods, side streets off Times Square. Always out of the way.
JM: But the Stonewall location was unique because it was in the center.
MB: Absolutely. Center. That was the allure. That’s one of the reasons we went, because we’re always there. We had to go to the bar somewhere. But there it was, right in the center.
So what happened was he got out of the truck, and he closed it up and clanked it, and I was like, “This is too much.” And he told us, like always they tell us, “You faggots came came for a show. Is this what you wanted to see? Now get the fuck out of here.”
And like always — like every single time I could remember since I was out, and those are years now, even though I was young — we started to turn around and listen to him, the policeman. But here it didn’t happen. All of a sudden, everybody turned and started moving towards him. I remember moving myself, the momentum. Slow, turtle-like in the momentum, but determined. There was an energy —
JM: And no one said “move toward him.” It just happened en masse.
MB: It just happened. And it was a group, and I didn’t know how far we were gonna go, but with the group I went. And he had his back was to us, and I saw the hairs on his neck go up, and he turned around and raised that stick. He blinked, he gulped, and he ran to the bar.
And all around that semicircle was enough police provocation to start trouble, and together it ignited a riot. Because there was so much to think of — I know, because I talked to queens later — People disappeared, great legends of the Village at the time. Great legends, Miss Crisis and Miss Wanda and these great queens, and they were gone.
And they’re all gone, and their legend lives. “Oh, you should’ve met —” It’s always, “You should’ve met her,” and she’s gone. That’s all. No questions. Gone. Either they were maimed — and we all knew somebody — or were homeless now, because they were thrown out of their family house, because the police notified their parents, or in mental institutions. So many victims. And so many nice, interesting queens. It did go through our minds: Where are they? And it was Miss Lily Law who did it.
JM: Who was Lily Law?
MB: Lily Law is the police. Miss Lily Law.
And there they were. It was like being in the dark and all of a sudden having your tormentors under your control. That feeling is almost indescribable. The feeling of revenge is so paramount in any way you can achieve it, even psychologically. It’s incredible how it can take you over, and that’s what happened. Because they locked themselves in the doorways of Stonewall, with the speakeasy signs in there. You could see their faces laughing, laughing at us.
JM: The police officers, when they hid in Stonewall — they were laughing?
MB: Because — faggots! They thought it was very funny. And all of a sudden, people started throwing pennies, coppers, and then whatever you had. And then the crowd got bigger and more unified.
JM: When did more police arrive?
MB: Oh, at this point. It took a while, because they didn’t take us seriously. When they got the call that a bunch of faggots were rioting, it was like: What, are they throwing roses at the bar? Pansies? Nobody could imagine what was going —
JM: Oh, so the police didn’t hurry —
MB: Oh, they were in no hurry. They were just a bunch of faggots — we’ll take care of it. We’ll sweep it up and clean it up. Bunch of faggots. It was simple, and we knew it. And you could tell they knew it. And then it got serious. It really got serious. I don’t think the police started to realize inside how serious it was getting, because windows started smashing, and the crowd got bigger, and stores were being ravaged — not for greed, for frustration. Because a riot has a lot of frustration in it.
JM: It spread to other storefronts?
MB: Up and down the block. People knew the adrenaline had to be released, so they were going out to find ammunition. Orange peels. There was an orange store nearby that served orange juice, so we could throw that. Garbage, so we could throw that. Eventually bricks came, but they were hard to find.

JM: I read somewhere that someone pulled up a parking meter?
MB: That was the big thing. So it was getting crazy. A riot is not a good thing. It’s like you’ve got a riot, you’ve gotta watch this part. No, “I’ll join this part, and I’ll join that part. Or I’ll get a little rest now, and I’ll join the…” No, it’s a huge, crazy swirl in which your senses are no longer your own. A swirl and a smell of testosterone and burning wood and burning cloth and adrenaline, and you can’t see. There’s no leader. You’re just moving for the next person in front of you and making a circle because of this madness, just because people had energy. What to do with it? They went berserk.
And in the midst of this came the most horrifying sound you’ll ever hear in the middle of a riot: silence.
The entire street went silent. Everything went silent. We all stopped. We were all like, “Why has it gone so silent?” Except for a thump, a thumping, a strange thumping, and then the crowd opened up, and there they were, the tactical police force. They were designed to fight the Black Panthers and the Weathermen, dressed in shields for their faces and shields for their bodies and gas masks and gas canisters and everything you could possibly think of. And someone yelled out, “My God, they’re in drag.” And they stood there, the crème de la crème of men, with their shields down, their legs open, like the valiant Roman legionaries. Impenetrable wall. And that wall was gonna come at us.
JM: You said that someone yelled, “Oh my God, they’re in drag.” That makes me laugh. Was it too scary to laugh?
MB: She meant they’re really done. They’re done.
JM: So it wasn’t a joke?
MB: They’re in drag. This is their drag. Girls, this is their drag. This is their night. This is their night.
JM: What happened after they arrived?
MB: Well, they looked at us, and they were furious that they were called in to put down a riot over a bunch of pansies. And they were furious at their commanders. They were furious, and they were in a very bad mood. It was very bad for us. Very bad. Oh my God, what to do? What to do? And then they did the famous kick line. Twenty queens got together, and in front of these massive Teutonic butchers sang, “We are the Stonewall girls. We wear our hair in curls,” and winking at them.
That was it. The charge. They charged us — and it’s like in the movies. My God, it is horrible, and we fled. However, we had two advantages. All these attacks on us — every time we went to the movies, or Saturday night, and there’d be a bu— “Oh, look, there’s a bunch of faggots.” They try to beat us up. We had to disperse and re-meet in order to enjoy the night, and we always found each other. It made us excellent urban guerrillas. And we knew the territory. They did not, because when they chased us, we wound up behind them. They couldn’t fucking believe it.
JM: For people who don’t know, most of New York is a grid, but the Village has winding roads that don’t connect and dead ends. You guys knew this better than anybody.
MB: We knew exactly where it was. We knew exactly. That’s how we were going up behind them. So we led them on this crazy goose chase. Now mind you, we’re going down neighborhoods where people are opening their windows, seeing all these gay people running down the street with police after them. They couldn’t believe it. What could gay people do to have this happen? They knew gay people in the Village. How could this be happening? There was pandemonium through the whole Village.
JM: Roughly how many gay men?
MB: It started off maybe 150 of us. It whittled down to the diehards.
JM: Obviously this is scary, but was part of it also fun?
MB: No.
JM: It wasn’t?
MB: When you hear about fun at Stonewall, it’s the second day, the third day, the fourth day — not the first day. It was not fun. There’s no way that was fun. I got scraped in the back with that billy club. I didn’t know until the next day, in the shower. I’m like, “God.”
JM: How did it die out that night?
MB: It’s just — the sun came. But the point of it was to stop us, and we knew that. So the point for us was not to be stopped. Not that we’re doing anything, but we’re still running. And that to the police meant we’re getting away with it. As long as we kept running, it was like, what a crazy cat-and-mouse game, but one we were willing to play.
JM: Did you go back the next night? What was the intention there? Because I would think you might be, rightfully, scared that the police would be waiting for you to come back the next night.
MB: Well, we were wary, but we wanted to see what happened. How could you stay home if they were down there? What could they do if we weren’t doing anything? So we all dressed down. We didn’t dress up. We even scaled down our scare drag.
JM: Had you been arrested in the past for scare drag?
MB: No. I was never arrested. You have a scare drag you can turn into a regular outfit in a second. You could be a hippie. All you needed was two minutes, if you were smart.
JM: Was Stonewall immediately recognized at the time as a big deal?
MB: No. What happened was very strange, because I wouldn’t say we talked about a riot, or that a riot was a big thing, but it was a big thing because all of a sudden, out of nowhere, without any warning, Christopher Street became more politicized than Moscow in 1917, more politicized than Paris in 1789.
JM: Politicized how? What did that look like?
MB: All of a sudden, there were people out there with posters they had made and pamphlets and all this stuff. All these agitators and people who were beginning to organize and calling on us, and had a head start in organizing, came out of the woodwork. So a lot of people had been sitting home thinking about this issue — more than we thought. It wasn’t just the entertainment aspect, in order to live our lives and enjoy our lives. Some people took it seriously, and they came out, and that was amazing. All of this politicization made a lot of gay people think of themselves, for the first time, in terms of politics. For the first time realizing that we have to fight this city. And how do you do that? You have to politicize yourself.
JM: So it changed the gay community.
MB: Absolute change.
JM: And it sounds like it made gay people in New York come together for the first time. It formed a community. It pushed you together.
MB: Yes — but it didn’t matter, because the A-Gays were still upset with drag queens. Nothing changed.
JM: I’m thinking of the Gay Liberation Front and the Gay Activists Alliance.
MB: What you’re talking about is the first march one year later. Now that was it. Now that was everything you’re talking about. Everything that you thought would happen at Stonewall the next day happened a year later. These activists, or some people, said, “There’s going to be a parade.” I said, “What?” “There’s going to be a parade,” they always said.
And it was just covered with multitudes of gay people who had never saw each other in the daylight, because we were cruisers. We were nocturnal people. Never did we look at each other. Never did we see each other. Never did we have anything in common with each other. And now all of a sudden people started holding hands, and arms got around shoulders, and the crowd was acknowledging each other. And this Latina queen on the hill was doing this dance of freedom, a modern dance. I never studied modern dance till then. And it was unbelievable. And then Bertie looked at me, because we’re on the hill looking down, and Bertie said, “I think we’re a people.” That’s when we became a people, that march.
It was beautiful. It was the most beautiful gay moment I’ve ever remembered.
JM: When did you start to view Stonewall as a significant moment in history?
MB: Only when others saw it.
JM: So it was years later.
MB: They called me. They were doing a book.
JM: A while after?
MB: Oh — 20 years later.
JM: I ask because it’s my understanding that all of us knowing what Stonewall was, gay and straight, is a fairly new development. I think even 15 years ago the vast majority did not know what happened at Stonewall. It was more or less beginning to be forgotten. Do you remember when people started to realize?
MB: It was about a book.
JM: By David Carter?
MB: The book did it. Because he investigated. He spent 10 years.
JM: Were you surprised when he even wanted to talk to you about Stonewall?
MB: To me it was like, “Wow, that’s great. I’m glad you’re doing it.” Somebody’s doing something. And then after that, I started becoming a one-month wonder. On June the phone would ring, and I was completely forgotten the other 11 months. But still, I was glad. And I started doing it and realizing how few we were. A lot of us died from drugs. Half of them died from drugs by ’75, and the other half died of AIDS. So we lost so many. We lost all the great fighters.
JM: There are so many misconceptions and myths about Stonewall. Are there any that are pet peeves for you, that you want to correct?
MB: We need legends and myths.
JM: You’re not bothered by them?
MB: No, of course not. That’s history. The Odyssey was just released as a movie. This is about myth and legend.
JM: I ask because there are debates about who threw the “first brick”, but those things don’t bother you personally?
MB: No, because myths are going to occur. If there is a myth, it means there is a subject. If there were no myth, there’d be no one, no subject. Because if they’re erroneous, they’re not harmful. “Someone threw the first brick.” Well, where were we gonna get a brick? Someone needs that.
JM: So the myths and the legends lead them back to the truth.
MB: It doesn’t matter whether Marsha was there or not. What matters is — unfortunately, as Imelda Marcos said something that was unbelievably true — that truth doesn’t matter, perception does. And that’s why the legend is important, because perception matters, not truth.
JM: During this time, you’re around 21-years old, what were you doing for work? Did you have a job?
MB: I was a student. I was going to college. That’s what was interesting. I was going to college, and from college go down all night and get a real education in the Village. And I brought that to college.
JM: What were you studying?
MB: History. But new stuff was coming up. We had a psychology class, and I was the only person, I think, to ever go to college at that point in scare drag. I went in scare. I wouldn’t do it now. It took balls.
JM: And your teachers were fine with that?
MB: They were not fine with it. It was a matter of whether I was a good student. And I was. That was the problem for them. Everybody tried to fail me, but it was impossible. I studied all night. When I cruised, I took books with me. I studied my ass off. I was gonna do well, because here was a scare drag representing my people.
And, oh my God, it made a lot of trouble, but we had to do a psychology paper about silent language — examples of the silent language, how we communicate without words. And I did two guys cruising. The teacher went out of his mind, and he said to me, “How can I take this as — what sources do you have?” I said, “The streets at night.” And he said, “I don’t understand.” I said, “Well, have you ever slept with a man?” He said, “No.” I said, “Well, then take my word for it.” And then he came to my side. People started admiring me because I wasn’t really stupid.
JM: That’s gumption.
MB: And it was tough. It was tough to be at the school. Then there became two more scare drags. They were all good students. All good students. So I took the street back with me, and it was very interesting to mix the street world and the academic world. It was fascinating. I got such a good education. I didn’t need to go to Harvard. It was all there. It was incredible.
Click here to listen to the full interview on the LGBTQ&A podcast.
LGBTQ&A features interviews with the most interesting lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer people in the world. Hosted and produced by Jeffrey Masters. @jeffmasters1
Most newsletters are annoying. This isn’t one of them.
Subscribe and never miss an update.

You must be logged in to post a comment.